The following piece makes the assumption that voting intention for Medway’s local elections in 2015 would have been the same under PR as FPTP. Whilst I’m open to the idea that this wouldn’t be the case (it almost certainly wouldn’t be -Jennings), this is the data I have to work with.
The essential principle is:
1 seat ward – Nearest to 100% wins a seat
2 seat ward – Nearest to 50% wins a seat
3 seat ward – Nearest to 33% wins a seat
Later, we will also look at a list system based on average votes across medway
Disclaimer:
If you are unable to make the leap this requires, stop reading, as you are unlikely to engage with the result. If however, you read on, then I look forward to hearing your thoughts.
Results data taken from www.medwayelects.co.uk, with thanks to Alan Collins.
Current Council : Conservatives 36, Labour 15, UKIP 3, Independent 1
For a possible, unlikely, interpretation of a PR Result, read on…
Chatham Central
Labour 34.9% = 1 Seat
UKIP 24.8% = 1 Seat
Conservatives 20.8% = 1 Seat
Running Total: Conservatives 1, Labour 1, UKIP 1
Cuxton and Halling
Conservatives 53.8% = 1 Seat
Running Total: Conservatives 2, Labour 1, UKIP 1
Gillingham North
Labour 33% = 1 Seat
UKIP 27.2% = 1 Seat
Conservatives 20.8% = 1 Seat
Running Total: Conservatives 3, Labour 2, UKIP 2
Gillingham South
Labour 29.6% = 1 Seat
UKIP 23.9% = 1 Seat
Conservatives 21.9% = 1 Seat
Running Total: Conservatives 4, Labour 3, UKIP 3
Hempstead and Wigmore
Conservatives 77.7% = 1 Seats
(Con 27.7% Remainder) = 1 Seat
Labour 17% = 0 Seats
Running Total: Conservatives 6, Labour 3, UKIP 3
Lordswood and Capstone
Conservative 66.3% = 1 Seat
(Con 16.3% Remainder) = 0 Seats
Labour 27.5% = 1 Seat
Running Total: Conservatives 7, Labour 4, UKIP 3
Luton and Wayfield
Labour 36% = 1 Seat
Conservatives 32.2% = 1 Seat
UKIP 26.2% = 1 Seat
Running Total: Conservatives 8, Labour 5, UKIP 4
Peninsula
UKIP 36.8% = 1 Seat
Conservatives 36.1% = 1 Seat
Labour 15.2% = 1 Seat
Running Total: Conservatives 9, Labour 6, UKIP 5
Princes Park
Conservatives 46.1% = 1 Seat
UKIP 27.5% = 1 Seat
Running Total: Conservatives 10, Labour 6, UKIP 6
Rainham Central
Conservatives 48.4% = 1 Seat
UKIP 24.5% = 1 Seat
(Conservative Remainder 15.4%) = 1 Seat
Labour 14.9% = 0 Seats
Running Total: Conservatives 12, Labour 6, UKIP 7
Rainham North
Conservatives 47.7% = 1 Seat
UKIP 24% = 1 Seat
Running Total: Conservatives 13, Labour 6, UKIP 8
Rainham South
Conservatives 46.5% = 1 Seat
UKIP 26.2% = 1 Seat
Labour 20.5% = 1 Seat
Running Total: Conservatives 14, Labour 7, UKIP 9
River
Conservatives 41.1% = 1 Seat
Labour 27.4% = 1 Seat
Running Total: Conservatives 15, Labour 8, UKIP 9
Rochester East
Labour 37.1% = 1 Seat
Conservatives 25.9% = 1 Seat
Running Total: Conservatives 16, Labour 9, UKIP 9
Rochester South and Horsted
Conservatives 38.4% = 1 Seat
UKIP 24.2% = 1 Seat
Labour 20.7% = 1 Seat
Running Total: Conservatives 17, Labour 10, UKIP 10
Rochester West
Conservatives 42.3% = 1 Seat
Labour 21.8% = 1 Seat
Running Total: Conservatives 18, Labour 11, UKIP 10
Strood North
Conservatives 36.4% = 1 Seat
Labour 25.8% = 1 Seat
UKIP 25% 1 Seat
Running Total: Conservatives 19, Labour 12, UKIP 11
Strood Rural
Conservatives 41% = 1 Seat
UKIP 35.1% = 1 Seat
(Conservative remainder 8%) = 0 Seat
Labour 16% = 1 Seat
Running Total: Conservatives 20, Labour 13, UKIP 12
Strood South
UKIP 37.4% = 1 Seat
Conservatives 34.5% = 1 Seat
Labour 25.8% = 1 Seat
Running Total: Conservatives 21, Labour 14, UKIP 13
Twydall
Labour 40.8% = 1 Seat
(Labour Remainder 7.8%) = 0 Seat
Conservatives 36.8% = 1 Seat
Greens 11% = 1 Seat
Running Total: Conservatives 22, Greens 1, Labour 15, UKIP 13
Walderslade
Conservatives 46.1% = 1 Seat
UKIP 24.6% = 1 Seat
Running Total: Conservatives 23, Greens 1, Labour 15, UKIP 14
Watling
Conservatives 41.1% = 1 Seat
Liberal Democrats 22.9% = 1 Seat
Total: Conservatives 24, Greens 1, Labour 15, Liberal Democrats 1, UKIP 14
Whilst this dramatically reduces the Conservative majority, in favour of UKIP, they would have a councillor in every ward. The majority of wards would have a mixed party of councillors representing them. The council would also benefit from having Green and Liberal Democrat voices represented.
I don’t want to cast aspersions with regard to the benefits of certain individuals who would not currently be councillors. I would like to say there was some potentially good individuals who are not currently councillors, who in this mix, would have been.
PART TWO: The List
Based on available data of voter averages from May 2015
Conservatives 32.8%
UKIP 24.2%
Labour 21.3%
Greens 8.1%
Liberal Democrats 7.1%
Independents 4.2%
TUSC 2.3%
Total Seats: Conservatives 18, Greens 5, Labour 12, Liberal Democrats 4, TUSC 1, UKIP 13, Independent 2
With a result that would reduce the main parties this much and increase the UKIP, Liberal Democrats and Greens result, you can understand why there is such an establishment reaction against PR.
But we can say it’s because of the maths.
Also any result that could lead to TUSC winning a seat, despite having a Zero Vote Ward in Rainham North, is clearly flawed and the system should stay the representative FPTP..
PUCK
If we shadows have offended,
Think but this, and all is mended,
That you have but slumber’d here
While these visions did appear.
And this weak and idle theme,
No more yielding but a dream,
Gentles, do not reprehend:
if you pardon, we will mend:
And, as I am an honest Puck,
If we have unearned luck
Now to ‘scape the serpent’s tongue,
We will make amends ere long;
Else the Puck a liar call;
So, good night unto you all.
Give me your hands, if we be friends,
And Robin shall restore amends.